The research done on this website is made possible by commissions earned through sales from affiliate links shared within the content. Learn more here.
When it comes to mattress toppers, those searching the market are normally after the product for one of two reasons - either to add comfort to a new mattress or to bring more life to an old mattress.
Either way, comfort is normally the main objective, and it’s something we’re going to explore today. In our experience, there are three main considerations to keep in mind while browsing the market;
- Secure fit - Ideally, the mattress topper will be fitted securely with built-in straps or fitted corners, so you don’t have to worry about putting it back into position every night (or even during the night!).
- Temperature - The last thing we want from a mattress topper is to spend all night rolling around in puddles of sweat. With this in mind, more and more manufacturers are using breathable materials. Depending on your preference for comfort, you might choose latex, gel memory foam, down alternative, or another material that offers sufficient ventilation.
- Firmness - Thirdly, we’re going to quash a misconception by saying that soft mattress toppers should still have some firmness. If they were completely soft, we would just sink into the mattress. Instead, it’s typically more comfortable to have some degree of support; the level of support you choose will be down to your personal preference.
After these considerations, there are others to remember, and we’re going to explore them a little later (including whether the topper is hypoallergenic and machine-washable). However, we’re getting ahead of ourselves. Instead, let’s start with our picks for the best soft mattress toppers on the market today.
The Best Soft Mattress Toppers
- Cloud9: the softest memory foam soft mattress topper
- SUFUEE: the most durable soft mattress topper
- Leisure Town: the best soft mattress topper for comfort
- Perfect Cloud: the best soft mattress topper for hot sleepers
- Pure Green: the softest latex soft mattress topper
- The Duck and Goose Co.: the best hypoallergenic soft mattress topper
- eLuxurySupply: the softest bamboo mattress topper
- PlushBeds: the softest wool mattress topper
Table of Contents
The Best Soft Mattress Toppers Comparison Table
- No toxic ingredients
- Soft and noiseless microfiber shell
- Made of 100% cotton
- Stretch knit material
- Adheres to strict VOC standards
- Light and breathable fabric
The Best Soft Mattress Toppers Reviews
Cloud9: The Softest Memory Foam Mattress Topper
As you’ve probably guessed from the name, this mattress topper feels like floating on a cloud, and it’s a sensation that will never get old. With a formula unique to the brand, you won’t find the same experience elsewhere, and this is perhaps why it has generated such interest online. In total, there are 3.3 inches of visco-elastic memory foam, made right here in the US. Cloud9 is incredibly soft and not as dense as you might expect from memory foam.
As a little word of warning, you may think the topper is firm for the first few minutes. Don’t panic; it will quickly pick up on your body temperature and conform to your shape. Soon enough, the weight will distribute evenly, the pressure points get relief, and you enjoy a night of sleep with the comfort you didn’t even know possible. This clever topper can even boost blood circulation, which can also encourage deeper sleep.
Sometimes, we don’t have the money to throw an old mattress away and replace it instantly. Therefore, this topper is a great way to breathe a new lease of life into a dying mattress. If you haven’t bought a memory foam product previously, there could be a slight smell while unpacking. If you leave it to one side for 24 hours, the smell should disappear, and it should also expand to its full size. Along with a superb 20-year limited warranty, you can also be confident that the topper contains no toxic ingredients.
SUFUEE: The Most Durable Option
If you find that your memory foam mattress is a little too firm, the SUFUEE mattress topper is a perfect solution. Not only will it add a fluffy and soft surface to your mattress, but it’s also one of the most durable toppers around. Made from down alternative, it’s hypoallergenic while boasting a microfiber shell. All things combined, it can provide relief to pressure points and also helps those with allergies (due to the Oeko-Tex Standard 100 verification).
In terms of the surface itself, we love the softness, but we also enjoy the lack of noise when moving it. As we sleep, the breathable fabric reacts to our temperature. In the summer, the body gets warmer, and the topper will wick moisture away as quickly as possible. Alternatively, on a cool day, it will wick moisture at a slower rate, and this should keep you warm.
With a thickness of two inches, it stays in place thanks to corner straps and is suitable for any mattress between 6 and 18 inches. When ordering, the topper will arrive in a box, and everything is sealed to maintain the high quality. After opening, allow the topper to inflate fully before using, and it will be ready to use. Whenever it needs freshening, just put it in the machine.
Leisure Town: The Most Comfortable Soft Mattress Topper
Next up, we have the best soft mattress topper for comfort, and it all starts with the HNN Cooling Technology that produces a cloud-like surface. This, combined with 100% cotton and 300-thread count, allows the topper to have luxurious levels of comfort without the sweat and heat. Rather than using diamond-quilted seams, Leisure Town has a new supportive shape, and all this combines to provide a comfortable night.
Whenever we mention cooling technology, we know there will be some people thinking ahead to winter. Will it come back to bite us in the colder months? No, the cooling technology is simply present to regulate airflow. This improves breathability, but it doesn’t create cold in the winter.
As a down-alternative fill, we get the comfort of duck and goose down but without the potential allergy problems (and even without feathers poking our skin through the sheet!). With a cotton cover, the whole product is thick enough to deal with spills and keep your mattress stain-free. With this topper, you’re not just getting a more comfortable bed; you’re prolonging the life of your mattress.
With the fabric sides, all mattresses with a thickness of up to 21 inches will be suitable for the topper. No matter how much you move, you shouldn’t have to worry about the topper sliding. Whenever it needs cleaning or fluffing, you can throw it in the washer and dryer too.
Perfect Cloud: The Best Option for Hot Sleepers
As we switch our attention to the best soft mattress topper for hot sleepers, we find one that might surprise many because it’s made of memory foam. Conforming to the contours of the body, it has Gel care cooling technology to prevent overheating. Rather than the memory foam holding onto the heat and you sweating, this technology regulates temperature, and you shouldn’t have a problem staying comfortable all night.
When we go to bed with shoulder, head, or neck pain, this causes nervous tension, and we find it hard to get a restful sleep. With this mattress topper, the nervous tension is removed, and you shouldn’t wake up through the night (or in the morning), feeling as though you haven’t slept at all. If you’ve been craving a deep and restful sleep, this might just be the way to get it.
When first applying the topper, many people feel the need to lay on it without a sheet because of the premium textile stretch knit cover. As a plush quilted cover, it feels amazing in itself. Designed in the US, the product is CertiPUR-US certified, and comes with brilliant customer service on Amazon. What’s more, the 10-year warranty will keep you protected while buyers on Amazon will also enjoy a 30-day trial.
Pure Green: The Softest Latex Mattress Topper
With no fillers involved anywhere in the manufacturing process, this all-natural latex mattress topper is a great way to find balance with comfort and support. For those who find themselves constantly twisting and turning or just struggling to drift off, it should encourage a restful sleep without waking up the next morning feeling achy.
If you’re wondering why you might choose latex over other materials, latex prevents the sinking feeling you get with a memory foam (you also get added durability!). Pure Green uses the Dunlop production process, which means more of a springy feel.
If you sleep on your side and you’ve noticed that your firm mattress leaves your shoulders and hips a little stiff in the mornings, the Soft topper option will feel great because it conforms to the body. However, if you need more support, the manufacturer also offers Firm and Medium versions of this topper.
In terms of temperature regulation, Pure Green exceeds with this topper, and it’s something you should notice from the first night. Not only does it not absorb body heat, but your own temperature also won’t adjust the firmness as it often happens with memory foam. In case you didn’t know, latex has very small air chambers, which is why it’s considered an ‘open-celled’ material. If you have a memory foam mattress and find yourself sleeping too hot, the topper creates somewhat of a buffer since the chambers allow air to pass through.
Depending on your requirements, Pure Green has thickness options between one and three inches and five different sizes. Just in case you’re worried about the material itself, it adheres to strict VOC standards - it has been through testing in numerous independent labs.
The Duck and Goose Co.: The Best Hypoallergenic Option
As we come to our next suggestion, we find The Duck and Goose Co. Don’t be fooled by the name, this topper is actually made from a comfortable, light and breathable down alternative, so you don’t have to worry about allergies and the poking feathers. Instead, there are around two inches of thickness, it doesn’t retain body heat like memory foam, and there’s also no chemical smell. Thanks to the stitching and anchor bands, you should get a secure fit on any mattress from 6 to 22 inches.
The Duck and Goose Co. is a known brand in this field, and this particular product has been designed with comfort in mind. By avoiding genuine down, it opens the topper to a wider market. Once you add in the pressure point relief and plush microfiber filling, you can be confident in a good sleep night after night.
If you plan on washing the topper, we recommend putting it on a low heat tumble dry, and the fibers will fluff up, ready for the next use. With a fitted sheet and even a mattress protector, you can reduce the need for washing and extend your topper’s life. If something happens to go wrong, take advantage of the 10-year warranty on this product.
eLuxurySupply: The Softest Bamboo Mattress Topper
As long as your mattress is under 18 inches deep, this extra-thick bamboo mattress topper will fit well while aiding your sleep. For an authentic goose and duck down feel, eLuxurySupply uses Revoloft fiber. Of course, this great feel comes without poking feathers, allergies, and other problems associated with genuine down.
Primarily, the topper is soft, and this is likely to be the first thing you notice. During your first night, the second thing will be the cooler sleep. Since bamboo is a porous material, it increases cooling and allows air to flow through. Best of all, the topper doesn’t contain toxic or allergy-causing materials.
As we noted in the key features, the cover offers a double-needle baffle box stitch with a 160-thread count; with these, the topper shouldn’t move as you do. If all this isn’t enough, all customers get a 1-year warranty, and eLuxurySupply also works with innerspring, latex, memory foam, and other mattress materials.
PlushBeds: The Softest Wool Mattress Topper
If you’re looking for a thick and plush wool mattress topper, there aren’t too many better options that PlushBeds. With a three-inch loft, even those who sink too far on thinner toppers will find comfort here. Additionally, temperature regulation is a particular quality of wool, which means you’ll stay warm in winter and cool in summer.
Furthermore, we believe you should consider wool because it’s antimicrobial, so you shouldn’t have to worry about mildew, dust mites, mold, or other allergens. Also, it helps to relieve the pressure points. This PlushBeds topper boasts a certified organic quilted sateen cotton cover, and the wool filling itself is 100% eco-friendly.
Unlike other manufacturers, PlushBeds doesn’t treat the wool with chemicals. Some companies use dyes, scouring agents, and other chemicals which can cause allergic reactions. With PlushBeds, you’re in better hands (not to mention the wool is sourced and produced in the US). So, even highly sensitive people should be fine with this topper.
Finally, we also want to mention the fact that the topper is cruelty-free. Fortunately, the brand has a strict wool assurance policy to ensure that all flocks are treated humanely and ethically. From growing to shearing, no sheep are treated poorly, so we can have peace of mind when sleeping on the fantastic topper.
Should You Get A Soft Mattress Topper?
If you’re wondering whether a mattress topper would benefit your nights, allow us to explain who would and wouldn’t enjoy this product. Should you get a soft mattress topper?
- Certain Health Conditions - If you work out regularly or are perhaps in the recovery phase after an injury, a soft topper will provide some relief. Whether it’s playing sports, working out, or just a generally active lifestyle, a soft topper will assist.
- Preference - Of course, we also say a big ‘yes’ to anybody who just loves having a soft topper. You may like being enveloped by your bedding, the plush feeling when getting into bed after a hard day, and just sinking deeper every night.
- Back Sleepers - If you sleep on your back, you may know that the balance between support and comfort is essential. When your mattress has no give, the hips sit tensely, and this can affect the lower back. With a soft topper, the hips can sink a little and you also get lumbar support.
- Lighter People - If you’re looking to sink a little into a mattress, adding a soft mattress topper will be a wise idea. For those who are slightly heavier, a soft topper can still be a good idea if you have a firm bed causing strains.
- Side Sleepers - Sleeping on your side can be incredibly uncomfortable when on a firm mattress; with excessive pressure on the hips and shoulders, it’s only a matter of time before these aches and pains become unbearable. To increase comfort and reduce the pressure, add a soft topper.
- Dislike Sinking - Firstly, those who dislike the sinking sensation that comes with a soft mattress topper should think twice. If you prefer to sleep on top of the mattress topper, you should be looking for a firmer product.
- Stomach Sleepers - Compared to back and side sleepers, stomach sleepers need much more support, and this is why we advise against soft toppers. Without the hips sinking and causing problems for the lumbar area, you should be looking for even support across the whole body.
Things To Consider Before You Buy
Before we finish with some frequently asked questions, we first want to take you through some buying considerations that need to be kept in mind when choosing a soft mattress topper.
Often, we pay too much attention to support, material, filling, and all sorts of other factors that we forget comfort. Although preferences will change from one person to the next, most people will find softer toppers more comfortable. While firmer toppers see the sleeper resting on top, softer toppers allow for more sinking. Whichever you prefer, choose one that YOU will find comfortable so that you get the sleep you deserve (and need!).
Density and Thickness
In terms of thickness, the widest range is normally found with foam; you’re likely to find everything between one and eight inches. Meanwhile, two inches is around the norm for down alternatives and down itself, and this is a good thickness for those who are heavier and/or sleep on their side. With density, your choice depends on the level of support you require. The higher the density, the more support sleepers can expect.
It isn’t one of the most important factors, but noise reduction is certainly something else to remember. Memory foam tends to absorb sound as well as movement which makes it ideal for couples. Normally, it’s the cover that makes noise with toppers, so we recommend reading customer reviews and even feeling different materials in physical stores (even if you order online after this testing!).
Both latex and memory foam excels in conforming to the body and providing support in all the right areas. When stress builds up, one of these toppers can mold to your body shape and keep it supported through the night.
In truth, answering the question of pricing with mattress toppers is difficult because it all depends on the type, material, quality, and brand. While cheaper materials include down alternatives and polyfoams, the most expensive models include latex, memory foam, and down. Before searching, why not set a budget and then find a topper that fits into this limit?
Can you wash the topper in the machine? Or can you remove the cover for machine washing? These are two questions to ask because this will be important in keeping the topper fresh. Historically, foam products are harder to keep clean; they can’t go in the machine and instead require a light cleaning solution and spot cleaning.
Warranty and Protection
As the final buying consideration, you might want to look at the protection offered by the manufacturer. While some companies offer a few months, others go for a decade or even lifetime protection. Don’t just look at the duration of a warranty, however, because they all cover different things. For example, a warranty considered ‘standard’ will cover exceptional wear and tear as well as manufacturer errors.
What’s the best soft mattress topper for a firm mattress?
When attempting to negate a firm mattress, we need something that eases our weight into the mattress. However, the quicker we sink, the less support and pressure point relief we’re likely to get. Therefore, the answer isn’t necessarily ‘as soft as possible.’ With the softness, you also need thickness. When choosing a product, you need to consider your body type and then go for thickness and density that match. Once you have this, you should get the right level of support while still remaining soft to the touch.
Why should I consider using a soft mattress topper?
Over the years, plenty of people have enjoyed the benefits of a soft topper or pad. They provide additional support, pressure point relief, and comfort. Not only this, but they can also help us to save money. Rather than spending out on a whole new mattress when it gets old, we can bring it back to life with a topper. This way, we’re spending a couple of hundred dollars rather than thousands.
What’s the best soft mattress topper for back pain?
After a long day with an aching back, you want your bed to be the safe haven you deserve. With this in mind, you need a soft topper that will relieve aches and pains. Look for one that distributes weight evenly, provides pressure point relief, and allows you to sleep comfortably. In most cases, the answer will come with soft latex or memory foam. If the problem gets worse or is already severe, go for a thicker topper.
You don’t have to buy a whole new mattress just to feel like you’re floating on a bed of clouds; the answer you could be looking for is actually with a high-quality mattress topper. While soft toppers don’t necessarily suit everybody, they do have big markets in side and back sleepers, lighter people, and those with certain health conditions and injuries.
Even if you share your bed with a partner or suffer from shoulder or hip pain, a soft topper can actually work wonders without requiring a huge investment. With so many different brands, materials, types, and designs on the market, we recommend considering your own needs before then finding a product to match. Often, people don’t think about themselves, and they’re left with a topper that doesn’t work for them as well as it could.
With the right topper, you’ll have a deep and restful sleep night after night while enjoying pressure point relief and the right amount of support!